News Alert


Hirschfield and Kula
  now on Saturdays at 5pm
KXL Newsradio 750
Portland, Oregon

Get intelligent!

 

Books

Brad's book

Movies

Building Bridges: Abrahamic Perspectives on the World Today
with Rabbi Brad Hirschfield, Season II

Now Available on a 3-DVD Set

A first-ever 15-part series conceived by a rabbi for Bridges TV-American Muslim TV Network, the show brings together religious leaders of the three major Abrahamic faiths to grapple with the divisive issues splitting our traditions and country. Fast paced and tied to today's news, it gives viewers a deeper understanding of how people of faith see the world, and each other, with live interviews from the American public.

Brad's Building Bridges

Price: $25.00 (3 DVD Set)
To order, click here.

Freaks Like Me



Time for a New God

Members Login

Members log in to comment on articles.

Podcast

Hirschfield & Kula and
IntelligentTalkRadio.com
is produced and managed by
Scott Newman Productions

Brad Blog Dec 26, 2007 Print E-mail
Wednesday, 26 December 2007
Digg!

Google!

Facebook!

StumbleUpon!
Will Smith, Hitler, and Us
fresh-prince-of-bel-air-will-smith.jpg posted by Brad Hirschfield in reaction to actor Will Smith's comments about Hitler
No, Will Smith did not say that Hitler was a good guy. Yes, Will Smith made the following remarks over the Christmas weekend: "Even Hitler didn't wake up going, 'let me do the most evil thing I can do today.' I think he woke up in the morning and using a twisted, backwards logic, he set out to do what he thought was 'good." And I am glad that he did!
Now will I get into trouble?

The point is that running around calling bad people who do terrible things “evil” and pontificating about how bad we really think they are, is nothing more than an exercise in self-congratulation for our being better than them. If we were serious about making sure that there were no more Hitlers, or at least fewer of them, and that our responses would be quicker and more successful than one that allowed twelve million innocent victims to die, we would do exactly what Will Smith has done i.e. try to understand the dynamics by which vicious hateful ideologies successfully wrap themselves in the garments of positive social change.

But, because most of us are afraid that when we admit that people often do terrible things, not because they are sick or cowardly, but because they are trying to make a contribution to the world, we somehow soften our objection to the means they use of the goal they pursue. In fact, it is only when we identify the seductive kernel of positive motivation that is present, that we can effectively engage and if need be, actually fight those who pursue hate and violence. Pure hate or anger actually burn themselves out pretty quickly, but it is the marriage of a drop of goodness and a ton of hate and anger that can sustain itself for long periods of time.

I know, it’s easier to simply piously mouth “I hate Hitler” than it is to really examine the hurts and angers of the world that are exploited by bad people. That doesn’t mean we excuse anyone who hurts or kills simply because they are hurt or angry. Once they have acted, they need to be punished. It simply means that among the tools we possess in our arsenal for fighting all people and ideologies that mask their fanatical hatred behind words of righteous indignation, is understanding – not acceptance of approval, but understanding. That understanding, combined with a more traditional arsenal is a powerful combination in any fight.


Comments
Add NewSearch
Only registered users can write comments!
 
< Prev   Next >
Read more Brad at Beliefnet.com

Brad's blog on beliefnet.com

Most Recent Irwin Blog

Irwin Blog June 2008
 
May- June 2008
CNN Radio “The Paula Gordon Show” 6/21/08
 
The New York Jewish Week 6/12/08

WASN
(Cleveland) “Louie B. Free Show” 5/22/08

PBS TV: The Jewish People: A Story of Survival, an original one-hour film explores these themes of resilience, fortitude and achievement of the Jewish people, moving chronologically over four millennia. Featuring Rabbi Brad Hirschfield, it is hosted by Martha Teichner, Senior Correspondent for “CBS News/Sunday Morning.”

5/7/08 WLIW NYC
6/1/08 WETA DC
6/2/08 WHYY, Philadelphia
6/4/08 KOCE, LA
6/5/08 WTTW, CHI

WORT-FM (Madison) “A Public Affair” 5/8/08

KPBS (San Diego) “These Days” 5/22/08
 
April, 2008
WRPI-FM (Albany) “In the Spirit” 4/24/08 
 
Open Court Tru-TV (formerly Court TV) 4/16/08 
 
The Morning Show, Wisconsin Public Radio 4/15/08
 
Religion News Service 4/15/08 
 
The Jewish News (New Orleans), 4/11/08
 
The Journal News (Gannet Westchester) 4/5/08
 
The Norman Transcript (Oklahoma) 4/4/08
 
April - June 2008
 
Voice of America 6/11/08 
 
“In the Spirit” WRPI- FM (Albany) 6/5/08
 
The Mitch Albom Show WJR-AM, Detroit 6/2/08
 
KOOP-FM (Austin) Soul Talk 4/17/08
 
The Drive with Steve Fast on WJBC (Central Illinois) April 14
 
Maria Sanchez Show on KVTA (Ventura, CA) April 14
 
 
The Jeff Farias Show, on Nova M Radio Network (Phoenix) April 10
 
The Pope’s visit with the Jewish community, and the sacredness of paying our taxes on the Louie B. Free Show Tuesday, April 8 at 2:05 pm EST, WASN, WRBP, and WGFT (all in the Cleveland/Pittsburgh area)

 
Arizona Daily Star 3/7/08

Brad & Irwin in the Arizona Daily Star 3/7/08

 

© 2008 Hirschfield and Kula